Navigating the Troubled Waters of the Maritime Middle East: A Strategic Dialogue with Admiral Gary Roughead

Table of Contents

Listen to this article

The Phoenix


In a recent episode of the American Center for Levant Studies’ podcast, “The Phoenix Podcast,” hosted by Joel Rayburn and Rania Kisar, a thought-provoking dialogue unfolded with Admiral Gary Roughead, former Chief of Naval Operations and commander of the Pacific Fleet. This conversation offered deep insights into the complexities of the maritime Middle East, focusing particularly on the Red Sea crisis, its geopolitical ramifications, and the strategic measures necessary for stability and security in the region.

Admiral Roughead’s Esteemed Naval Background

Admiral Gary Roughead, a highly distinguished figure within the United States Navy, brings an unparalleled wealth of expertise to the dialogue. With a remarkable 38-year naval career culminating in his role as Chief of Naval Operations from 2007 to 2011, he wielded immense influence in shaping naval strategy and operations, addressing multifaceted challenges spanning fleet modernization to global threats. His prior command of the expansive Pacific Fleet, stretching from the U.S. West Coast to the Indian Ocean and from the Arctic to the Antarctic, afforded him unique insights into the strategic dynamics of the Asia-Pacific region, of increasing global significance.

Moreover, Admiral Roughead’s firsthand experience in the volatile maritime regions of the Persian Gulf and Eastern Mediterranean further enriches his perspective. His time in these areas, marked by critical events and operations, grants him a profound understanding of naval operations within conflict-prone zones. His enduring contributions extend to his role as a distinguished military fellow at the Hoover Institution, where he continues to shape national security discourse.

In essence, Admiral Roughead’s career, encompassing strategic planning, operational experience in pivotal maritime theaters, and ongoing contributions to national security discourse, equips him with a comprehensive grasp of the intricate challenges in maritime security. His insights resonate as pivotal in comprehending current dynamics in the Red Sea and their far-reaching implications for U.S. naval strategy and global maritime stability.

The Evolving Maritime Middle East

In the podcast, a critical examination of the evolving landscape of the maritime Middle East reveals significant shifts impacting regional stability. Central to this discussion is the deteriorating security situation in Yemen, which serves as a focal point for broader regional tensions. Admiral Roughead zeroes in on Iran’s role, noting its deep-seated involvement in the area. This involvement is multifaceted, encompassing the deployment of proxies, provision of financial support, and impartation of operational guidance, all of which significantly contribute to the escalating crisis.

Particularly noteworthy is the discussion around the events of October 7th, a date marking a notable escalation in regional conflicts. This incident is seen as a cog in the larger wheel of Iran’s strategy, underscoring Tehran’s ambition to expand its influence across the maritime Middle East. The Admiral’s analysis points to these developments not as isolated events but as part of a coherent, larger strategy by Iran, intricately woven into the fabric of the ongoing regional power dynamics. This perspective sheds light on the complex interplay of geopolitical interests and the pivotal role of maritime strategies in shaping the current and future landscape of the Middle East.

Strategic Approach to Maritime Security

The dialogue emphasizes the imperative for a strategic approach to maritime security, transcending beyond mere defensive tactics. This paradigm shift is crucial in addressing the multifaceted nature of maritime threats. Admiral Roughead, with his profound experience, highlights the importance of coalition-based strategies, which are essential for effective maritime security operations. He underlines the complexities involved in assembling and maintaining such coalitions, particularly given the intricate political dynamics that influence international military cooperation. The Admiral strongly advocates for establishing a persistent and credible naval presence in key maritime regions. This presence is not only about displaying power but also about ensuring the safety and legality of maritime activities, which are vital for global commerce and peace. His perspective underscores the need for a comprehensive approach, integrating military prowess with diplomatic and political efforts to foster a secure and stable maritime environment.

Iran’s Ambitions and Maritime Power

The podcast delves deeply into the maritime ambitions of Iran, revealing a strategic intent focused on disrupting the free flow of commerce and asserting control over critical regional sea lanes. This aggressive posture, aimed at challenging the U.S. and its allies, is a cornerstone of Iran’s broader geopolitical strategy. Despite the Iranian navy’s limited capabilities, as noted in the conversation, the Revolutionary Guard Navy has emerged as a more formidable force, receiving greater resources and attention. This shift has significant implications for regional security, especially in the context of evolving maritime tactics. The discussion highlights the increasing use of drones and asymmetric warfare methods, particularly by the Houthi rebels in Yemen, as a growing threat. These tactics represent a new dimension in naval warfare, necessitating a reevaluation of traditional maritime security strategies. The conversation underscores the need for vigilance and strategic innovation in countering these emerging challenges posed by Iran and its proxies.

The Need for Comprehensive Strategies

The podcast conversation brings into sharp focus a unanimous agreement among the participants regarding the limitations of purely military-focused approaches in addressing complex strategic challenges. This shared perspective underscores the necessity of adopting a multifaceted strategy that integrates military, economic, and political dimensions. The discussion advocates for a balanced approach where political strategies are not just complementary but lead the way in crafting effective solutions.

This emphasis on political strategies at the forefront signifies an acknowledgment of the intricate nature of global conflicts and crises. It recognizes that sustainable solutions require more than just military might; they necessitate astute political maneuvering, diplomatic engagement, and economic measures. This approach is rooted in the understanding that the roots of many conflicts are often political, and as such, require political remedies.

Moreover, the conversation highlights the importance of economic strategies, which play a critical role in exerting pressure and incentivizing behavioral change among actors in a conflict. Economic sanctions, trade negotiations, and aid are tools that can be employed alongside military efforts to achieve desired outcomes.

Global Commerce and the Role of the U.S.

The podcast highlights the critical impact of disrupted maritime routes, especially in the Red Sea, on global commerce. These disruptions underscore the interconnected nature of global trade and the pivotal role played by maritime transit routes. As a leading maritime power, the United States bears a significant responsibility in safeguarding these crucial sea lanes. This responsibility is not only a matter of national interest but also a global imperative, given the U.S.’s capacity to influence and stabilize international maritime traffic. The discussion points out that ensuring the security of these routes is essential for the uninterrupted flow of global commerce, impacting economies worldwide. Therefore, the U.S.’s engagement in maritime security is seen as vital, not just in a military context but also as a part of broader international cooperation. This cooperation is key to maintaining open and safe sea lanes, thereby supporting global economic stability and development.

Technological Evolution and Asymmetric Threats

The discussion in the podcast provides a nuanced understanding of how technological evolution has reshaped the landscape of maritime security, particularly in the face of asymmetric threats. It draws attention to the way groups like the Houthis have adopted advanced technologies, such as drones, to execute asymmetric warfare tactics. This evolution marks a significant shift from traditional forms of naval confrontation, where the size and strength of a fleet were the primary indicators of maritime power. Now, smaller, non-state actors are capable of exerting substantial influence and causing considerable disruption using relatively low-cost and accessible technologies.

The emergence of these new tactics highlights the need for rapid development and deployment of effective countermeasures. The conversation underscores the importance of not only keeping pace with technological advancements but also staying a step ahead through strategic foresight. It implies that traditional naval powers must rethink their approach to maritime security, considering that their adversaries may not play by conventional rules of engagement. This situation calls for innovative solutions that can neutralize the threat posed by asymmetric warfare techniques, ensuring the safety and security of vital maritime routes.

Moreover, the dialogue suggests that the response to these emerging threats should not be purely reactive. Instead, it necessitates a proactive stance, integrating advanced surveillance, enhanced intelligence capabilities, and cutting-edge defense systems. Such an approach requires a comprehensive understanding of both the technology and the tactics employed by potential adversaries, reflecting a strategic shift in the way maritime powers must prepare for and engage in future naval conflicts.

Regional Impact and International Relations

The podcast delves into the significant regional and international consequences stemming from the diversion of shipping routes, particularly highlighting the economic strain on Egypt. This shift in maritime traffic, primarily due to security concerns in the Red Sea, has broader implications beyond immediate economic setbacks. It symbolizes a destabilizing factor for regional stability, as Egypt’s economy heavily relies on revenue from Suez Canal transit fees. This situation, in turn, affects international relations, as global trade dynamics are altered, impacting countries dependent on these routes for imports and exports. Additionally, the conversation sheds light on the complex political landscape of the region, emphasizing the necessity for a concerted international effort to apply political and economic pressure on Iranian proxies. This strategy is crucial not only for addressing the immediate threats to maritime security but also for mitigating long-term regional instability that could have far-reaching global repercussions. The dialogue underscores the interconnectivity of regional events and their cascading effects on the global stage, necessitating a vigilant and coordinated response from the international community.

Concluding Reflections: Charting a Course for Stability and Security

As the episode draws to a close, it crystallizes the imperative for continued dialogue and decisive action in tackling the intricate challenges facing the maritime Middle East. The discussion poignantly highlights the inextricable link between global maritime security and regional stability, bringing into sharp relief the urgency of adopting a unified and comprehensive strategy. This strategy must go beyond conventional measures, weaving together political acumen, economic leverage, and military strength to forge a path towards enduring peace and prosperity in these geopolitically significant waters.

In essence, the insights offered by Admiral Gary Roughead in “The Phoenix Podcast” serve as a compelling call to action. They underscore the necessity for a holistic approach – one that adeptly navigates the complex interplay of factors shaping the maritime Middle East. This approach must be agile yet firm, innovative yet grounded in realistic assessments, ensuring that the turbulent waters of the Red Sea and beyond are navigated with foresight and collaborative resolve. Only through such concerted efforts can we hope to secure a stable, prosperous future for the region and maintain the vital arteries of global maritime commerce.


Download the print version


    Your Voice:

    Your Name

    Your Email

    Word File:

    To subscribe to our daily mailing list, fill out the following form:

    Scroll to Top

    To subscribe to our daily mailing list, fill out the following form: